Sugar Free Cake Recipe: Moist, Naturally Sweet & Diabetic-Friendly

June 25, 2025

Sugar free cake with raisins and walnuts

Jump to Recipe·Print Recipe·Leave a Review

Sugar free cake recipe—those words used to sound impossible in my kitchen. When my dad was first diagnosed with type 2 diabetes, I assumed we had to say goodbye to cake forever. But I couldn’t let go of the idea of a soft, spiced slice shared over coffee or at birthdays. So I got creative. I swapped out refined sugar and leaned on natural sweeteners like applesauce, raisins, and liquid alternatives. What came out of the oven was magic: a moist, satisfying cake that felt like a hug. This sugar free cake recipe is all about comfort—without the compromise.

Rediscovering Cake Through a Sugar Free Cake Recipe

How a Family Diagnosis Changed My Baking Forever

When my dad’s blood sugar spiked into dangerous territory, we had to make big changes. Soda, store-bought cookies, and of course—cake—all went off the table. Watching him quietly miss his favorite desserts pulled at me. That’s when I started learning about naturally sweetened baking. It wasn’t easy at first. Some sugar substitutes left a bitter aftertaste. Others changed the texture entirely. But I kept experimenting in my warm little kitchen here in North Carolina, surrounded by the smells of cinnamon and vanilla.

This sugar free cake recipe was one of the first wins. Instead of refined sugar, it uses unsweetened applesauce, raisins simmered in water, and just a touch of liquid sweetener. The result? A dense but moist texture, deeply spiced with cinnamon and nutmeg, and just sweet enough to satisfy.

It’s not just a diabetic-friendly dessert. It’s a cake that feels nostalgic and comforting—without the blood sugar crash.

If you’ve tried my Sugar-Free Cookie Dough or Healthy Rice Crispy Cakes, you know the joy of desserts that taste indulgent but treat your body kindly. This cake does exactly that.

What Makes This Sugar Free Cake Recipe So Special?

Most sugar-free cakes are dry, flat, or overly dense. Not this one. This sugar free cake recipe gets its moisture from applesauce and vegetable oil, and its sweetness from a blend of raisins and a mild liquid sweetener—so there’s no sharp artificial flavor.

The spices do more than add warmth—they balance the richness from the nuts and the gentle fruit sweetness. The result is a cake you can serve at birthdays, brunch, or after dinner, and no one will ask if it’s sugar-free—they’ll just ask for seconds.

Even better? It’s incredibly forgiving. One bowl. One pan. No complicated techniques. And whether you’re baking for someone managing diabetes or simply cutting back on sugar, this recipe delivers full flavor without the stress.

Choosing Ingredients for the Perfect Sugar Free Cake Recipe

Smart Sweeteners – Why Liquid Works Best Here

When it comes to building a truly satisfying sugar free cake recipe, choosing the right sweetener isn’t just a preference—it’s essential. Not all sweeteners behave the same way in the oven. Some leave a strong aftertaste. Others dry out the crumb. This recipe uses a liquid sweetener, which blends seamlessly into the batter and pairs beautifully with the natural sugars in applesauce and raisins.

You only need a few tablespoons to achieve a balanced sweetness. Because the raisins are simmered until soft and plump, they carry some of that sweetness too. This means you’re getting layered flavor—not just a single hit of sugary taste.

And here’s the best part: unlike refined sugar, liquid sweeteners don’t spike blood sugar the same way. That makes this sugar free cake recipe a much better option for people watching their glycemic load. It’s the same smart swap I use in my Protein Muffins, where natural sweeteners work together to deliver taste and balance.

Measured ingredients for sugar free cake recipe — All ingredients arranged for naturally sweetened cake

This cake doesn’t taste “healthy” in that cardboard sort of way. It tastes cozy. Like fall afternoons and holiday tables. And it’s thanks to these thoughtful ingredient swaps that you won’t miss the sugar.

The Role of Applesauce, Raisins, and Spice

Applesauce plays a double role here—it keeps the cake moist and naturally sweet. Unlike dry sugar substitutes, applesauce brings structure and softness to the batter. Plus, it adds subtle fruit flavor that pairs beautifully with warm spices.

Raisins get simmered in water first, allowing them to soften and absorb moisture. They melt slightly into the crumb during baking, offering bursts of sweetness that don’t overwhelm. This is key to the cake’s overall texture—it’s tender, never crumbly.

Spices like cinnamon and nutmeg round out the flavor. They make this cake feel warm and comforting. The aroma alone could fill your entire home with cozy vibes. And the touch of vanilla? It ties everything together without being overpowering.

It’s a familiar flavor profile—like an old-fashioned spice cake—but reinvented through the lens of mindful baking. Just like my Greek Yogurt Blueberry Muffins, this recipe shows that thoughtful ingredients can elevate flavor, not just replace it.

Together, these elements create a balanced, moist, and flavorful cake that doesn’t feel like it’s “missing” anything. It feels whole—exactly as cake should.

How to Make This Sugar Free Cake (Step by Step)

Mixing, Folding, and Not Overbaking

This sugar free cake recipe comes together with simple pantry staples, a single mixing bowl, and no fancy tools. That’s what makes it so inviting. Whether you’re a seasoned baker or just starting out, this cake fits right into your rhythm.

Start by simmering the raisins in water. This step isn’t just for softness—it infuses the batter with rich, natural sweetness. Once the water has absorbed and the raisins are plump, let them cool while you mix the rest.

In a large bowl, whisk together the applesauce, vegetable oil, eggs, liquid sweetener, and vanilla. These wet ingredients form the base of the moist, flavorful crumb. Then sift in your dry ingredients: flour, cinnamon, baking soda, nutmeg, and salt. Stir just until combined.

Mixing sugar free cake batter with raisins and walnuts — Folding together moist sugar free batter

The batter will feel thick—but don’t worry. Once the raisins and walnuts go in, it becomes even richer. Pour it all into a greased Bundt or tube pan and smooth the top.

Bake at 350°F (175°C) for about an hour. You’ll know it’s done when a toothpick comes out clean or with just a few moist crumbs. Your kitchen will smell like cinnamon, vanilla, and warm memories.

This sugar free cake recipe delivers a perfectly domed top, a tender crumb, and deep golden edges that never dry out. It’s very forgiving—much like my Date Bark, which thrives on flexibility and flavor.

Pro Tips for Consistent Results

Here’s how to get bakery-level results every time.

Don’t overmix. Once the flour is in, stir gently. Overmixing can make the crumb tough instead of tender.
Let the raisins cool before adding. Adding them hot can activate the baking soda too early.
Grease your pan generously. Especially if using a Bundt pan, get into every groove to avoid sticking.
Cool completely. Let your cake rest in the pan for 10–15 minutes before flipping onto a rack. It firms up as it cools and slices cleaner this way.
Want smaller portions? Divide the batter into two loaf pans and reduce bake time slightly. This is perfect for freezing or gifting.

This cake freezes beautifully. Wrap individual slices and store them in an airtight container—just like I recommend for my Sugar-Free Donuts. A slice reheated with a bit of butter or served cold with tea makes the perfect anytime treat.

The process is straightforward, the results are consistent, and the flavor is always reliable. That’s the kind of recipe that earns a permanent place in your kitchen.

How to Customize This Sugar Free Cake for Any Occasion

Make It Festive with Frosting or Glaze (Optional)

One of the best things about this sugar free cake recipe is how versatile it is. You can serve it plain for everyday snacking or dress it up for birthdays and holidays. The warm, spiced base pairs beautifully with so many different toppings.

If you want to add a frosting, try a light sugar-free cream cheese glaze. Just blend softened cream cheese with a little vanilla, a splash of almond milk, and your favorite powdered sweetener until it’s silky and smooth. Drizzle it over the top and let it fall into the curves of your Bundt pan design—it looks elegant without being over-the-top.

For something simpler, a quick powdered erythritol glaze does the trick. Mix ½ cup of powdered erythritol with a tablespoon of lemon juice or water, and pour it over the cooled cake. It sets into a subtle sheen that adds sweetness and style.

You can also fold in some orange zest or chopped dates for a seasonal twist, or top the finished cake with thin apple slices and a dash of cinnamon for an autumn vibe. These tweaks don’t just add flavor—they make this sugar free cake recipe feel brand new every time you bake it.

Just like my Cottage Cheese Banana Bread, this recipe can evolve with your cravings. A few smart swaps, and you’ve got something uniquely yours.

Sugar free cake slice — A tender slice of sugar free cake

Storing, Freezing, and Making Ahead

This cake stores like a dream. Once it’s fully cooled, cover it tightly and keep it at room temperature for 2–3 days, or in the fridge for up to 5. The texture actually improves after a day—the spices settle, the moisture redistributes, and every bite becomes more balanced.

For longer storage, slice the cake and wrap each piece in parchment before sealing in an airtight container. It’ll stay fresh in the freezer for up to 2 months. To enjoy, just thaw at room temp or warm gently in the microwave.

This makes it perfect for meal prep, busy weeks, or planning ahead for family gatherings. Like with my Sugar-Free Pecan Pie, I often bake this the day before hosting. That way, dessert is done, the kitchen is clean, and I can just enjoy the company.

The best part? No one ever asks if it’s “sugar-free.” They just ask for seconds.

FAQs – Sugar-Free Cake Recipes

Is sugar-free cake ok for diabetics?

Yes—especially when made with whole ingredients and without refined sugar. This sugar free cake recipe uses natural sweetness from applesauce and raisins, plus a liquid sweetener that won’t spike blood sugar. It’s a smart dessert choice for those managing diabetes or cutting sugar for health.

Can you make a cake without sugar?

Absolutely. You can create a flavorful, moist cake without using any refined sugar. This sugar free cake recipe uses fruit-based ingredients, warm spices, and smart sweeteners to deliver taste and texture—without compromise.

Which cake is best for diabetics?

Look for cakes made with low-glycemic sweeteners, healthy fats, and whole ingredients—like this one. This sugar free cake recipe checks all those boxes. It’s rich, naturally sweet, and free from refined sugar, making it a better fit for diabetic-friendly diets.

Do sugar-free cakes exist?

Yes—and they can be delicious. This one proves that a sugar free cake recipe can be just as indulgent as the classic kind, with moisture from applesauce, deep flavor from raisins, and none of the sugar crash afterward.

When I first started baking without sugar, I was worried about losing what made desserts feel comforting. But this sugar free cake recipe changed everything. It’s not just about removing sugar—it’s about keeping the heart of the cake intact: flavor, warmth, and that homemade feel that brings people together.

Every bite reminds me of why I started this blog—to care for others through food. Whether you’re baking for someone with diabetes or just looking for a healthier option, this cake is proof that sweet can still mean satisfying.

If you loved this recipe, don’t miss some of our other naturally sweet favorites like Cottage Cheese Banana Bread and Healthy Rice Crispy Cakes. They’re just as comforting, simple, and real.

Let’s keep sharing the joy of healthy baking together:
🍰 Follow new bakes on Instagram
👩‍🍳 Join our baking conversations in the Let’s Make Recipes Facebook Group
📌 And don’t forget to like the main Facebook Page for weekly updates and tips from my cozy kitchen

Because dessert should feel like a hug—and now it can.

Loved this recipe? Share it!